
Qual è la differenza tra alimentazione disordinata e un disturbo alimentare?
Revisione paritaria di Dr Sarah JarvisUltimo aggiornamento di Emily Jane BashforthUltimo aggiornamento 8 Nov 2021
Rispetta le linee guida editoriali
- ScaricaScarica
- Condividi
- Language
- Discussione
- Versione audio
- Aggiungi alle fonti preferite su Google
Può essere difficile distinguere tra un'alimentazione disordinata e un vero e proprio disturbo alimentare (DA). Questo è particolarmente vero poiché viviamo in una cultura della dieta in cui si parla molto di perdita di peso, 'alimentazione pulita' e fitness. Tuttavia, è importante essere in grado di identificare una relazione tossica con il cibo e sapere dove cercare aiuto tempestivamente prima che le cose peggiorino.
What is disordered eating?
Dr Omara Naseem is a senior psychologist who describes disordered eating as 'symptoms of an disturbo alimentare which are at the subclinical level for diagnosis'.
This does not mean they aren't harmful or can be safely ignored. Symptoms of disordered eating still warrant attention, as early intervention is the key to stopping disordered habits becoming entrenched.
Disordered eating can include:
Limiting food intake.
Abbuffate - eating a very large amount of food at once and feeling out of control of eating.
Purging - making yourself sick or misusing lassativi.
Disordered habits are not limited to food, though, as someone might also engage in:
Cutting out food groups.
Extreme dieting.
Fasting.
Using diet teas.
Detoxes.
Cleanses.
Dr Naseem says disordered eating often represents the development of ED symptoms. These can wrongly be viewed as someone being 'healthy'.
"Preoccupation with food, and weight and body shape are the first physiological signs of undereating and often manifest in disordered eating," she says.
What is an eating disorder?
"Eating disorders are complex mental illnesses with the highest mortality rate of any mental health disorder," says Dr Naseem.
The peaks for an eating disorder to occur are in adolescence and young adulthood. However, eating disorders can develop before and after these timeframes too.
Disturbi alimentari do not discriminate. They affect all genders, ages, sexualities, races, socio-economic classes and people from all backgrounds.
There are four main categories of eating disorder:
Binge eating disorder.
Other specified feeding or eating disorder (OSFED).
Dr Naseem stresses that OSFED is no less serious than the other categories of eating disorders. It simply means that its symptoms don't fit the categories of anorexia nervosa, bulimia nervosa or binge eating disorder.
OSFED includes atypical anorexia nervosa, atypical bulimia nervosa, purging disorder and night eating syndrome. In older diagnostic systems, the term 'eating disorder not otherwise specified' (EDNOS) was used instead of OSFED.
Dr Naseem says it is very common for people to move between different eating disorder diagnoses over time.
"I want to highlight that all eating disorders are serious. I also want people to know that eating disorders aren't solely - or even mainly - about food. People with eating disorders often feel a lot of pain, sadness and worry. Recovery is about addressing other issues in their life also, and helping them develop coping strategies beyond controlling their food. However, there are effective treatments for all disorders."
When does disordered eating become an eating disorder?
"In my view, disordered eating would always warrant attention," says Dr Naseem.
"When disordered eating starts to interfere with daily life, this is an early warning sign of the development of an eating disorder. Disordered eating can lead to people withdrawing from situations, feeling preoccupied and having trouble concentrating. They may also have compulsive or rigid behaviours and show emotional distress."
In some cases, a person might have continued or rapid weight loss. However, this will not always happen, as eating disorders are not weight disorders and weight may be within normally accepted limits. A person does not have to be a set weight in order to have an ED, contrary to the misconceptions.
To be diagnosed with an eating disorder, a person must have symptoms that meet a certain threshold. The main purpose of a diagnosis is to create appropriate treatment plans, rather than to give people a label.
Dr Naseem explains that eating disorders should be diagnosed by GPs, trained eating disorder doctors, psychiatrists and psychologists.
How common is disordered eating?
It's rare nowadays to turn on the TV and not see an advert for a diet plan. Likewise, it's difficult to open a social media app and not see photoshopped images or influencers promoting weight loss products. We live in a diet culture, and Dr Naseem believes this has contributed to disordered eating becoming 'normalised'.
"I believe a rise in fitness and clean eating trends has led to a normalisation of disordered behaviours. This has undoubtedly skewed how people view healthy eating and body image ideals. It's important people know that 'health' looks different for everyone."
With social media often perpetuating harmful messages, people might not always realise they have a disordered relationship with food. Stereotypes around eating disorders can also lead to people believing they aren't 'sick enough'.
Does disordered eating always turn into an eating disorder?
"Disordered eating does not always develop into an eating disorder," Dr Naseem says.
She explains how vital early intervention is so people can get well again before their symptoms escalate and worsen. The sooner a person notices problematic behaviours and takes action, the faster they can make a full recovery.
What is the treatment process for a diagnosed eating disorder?
Treatment for an eating disorder depends on the diagnosis.
Dr Naseem says currently, the NHS will treat eating disorders in accordance with NICE guidelines in different ways.
Restrictive eating disorders are treated using the Maudsley model of anorexia nervosa treatment for adults - also known as MANTRA. They might also use terapia cognitivo-comportamentale (CBT).
Binge eating and bulimic disorders are treated with cognitive behavioural therapy.
OSFED is treated according to which symptoms are the most prominent in alignment with the most appropriate treatment model.
All approaches will incorporate dietetic input and medical monitoring.
However, if more intensive treatment is required, there are other options such as:
Daycare options involving meal support and psychological groups.
Occupational therapy input.
Family therapy input.
Inpatient stays in specialised eating disorder units for intensive hospital treatment.
Dr Naseem says it is not uncommon for someone to have a stepped care approach or a mixture of inpatient, to daycare, to outpatient (therapy once a week) treatment.
If you are struggling with food, where can you get support?
"If you are struggling with food, you should contact your GP. They should be the first port of call. Your GP can refer you to your local ED service and also perform appropriate health checks."
There are, however, long waiting lists for NHS treatment. Therefore, for immediate help, private therapy might be an option.
You can also reach out to eating disorder charity Beat, who offer free guidance and resources, and help in finding support.
Scelte del paziente per Disturbi alimentari

Salute mentale
Come aumentare di peso dopo aver avuto un disturbo alimentare
If you're in recovery from a restrictive eating disorder, weight gain might be a crucial part of that process. However, this can be a real challenge and often a painful process, even if you understand that it's right for your body. Gaining weight can be especially difficult if you've lived with an eating disorder for a long time and have a lot of aggressive, ingrained thoughts about what weight gain means.
di Emily Jane Bashforth

Salute mentale
Connessioni tra 'alimentazione sana' e ortorexia
Sulla superficie, mangiare in modo sano sembra una scelta positiva per la salute. Tuttavia, è una scelta che nasconde il potenziale di causare gravi preoccupazioni per la salute a lungo termine.
di Rose Constantine Smith, ANutr
Informazioni sull'autoreVisualizza il profilo completo

Emily Jane Bashforth
Scrittore di Articoli
NCTJ
Emily è una scrittrice di articoli per Patient, scrivendo articoli su una varietà di argomenti relativi alla salute e al benessere.
Informazioni sul recensoreVisualizza il profilo completo

Dr Sarah Jarvis
Consulente Clinico
MA (Cantab), BM, BCh (Oxon), DRCOG, FRCGP, MBE
Dopo aver completato la formazione in medicina a Cambridge e Oxford, la Dott.ssa Sarah Jarvis MBE è diventata un medico di base.
Storia dell'articolo
Le informazioni su questa pagina sono revisionate da clinici qualificati.
Articolo disponibile anche in Inglese, Tedesco, Spagnolo, Francese, Italiano, Portoghese, Hindi, Ebraico, Arabo, and Svedese.
8 Nov 2021 | Ultima versione

Chiedi, condividi, connettiti.
Esplora le discussioni, fai domande e condividi esperienze su centinaia di argomenti di salute.

Non ti senti bene?
Valuta i tuoi sintomi online gratuitamente
Iscriviti alla newsletter di Patient
La tua dose settimanale di consigli sulla salute chiari e affidabili - scritti per aiutarti a sentirti informato, sicuro e in controllo.
Abbonandoti accetti i nostri Informativa sulla Privacy. Puoi annullare l'iscrizione in qualsiasi momento. Non vendiamo mai i tuoi dati.
Più sulla salute mentale
- Può l'ADHD causare ansia e depressione?
- Il lutto: come affrontare la finalità della morte
- Come influisce il cambiamento climatico sulla salute mentale?
- Come affrontare lo stress di essere un nuovo genitore
- Come affrontare lo stress attraverso l'esercizio fisico
- Come affrontare la morte di un animale domestico
- Come aiutare se tuo figlio ha un disturbo alimentare
- Come aiutare tuo figlio con l'ansia da rientro a scuola
- Come gestire la gravidanza quando si ha un disturbo alimentare
- Come supportare qualcuno con psicosi
- Prepararsi alla perdita di una persona cara: come affrontare il dolore anticipato
- Riaccendere la scintilla - la scienza di trovare più gioia
- Dermatillomania e tricotillomania: gestire i comportamenti ripetitivi focalizzati sul corpo
- La realtà della vita dopo aver sopravvissuto a un tentativo di suicidio
- L'effetto Stranger Things: perché la nostalgia crea connessione e migliora il nostro umore
- Guarigione non convenzionale: l'ascesa delle terapie alternative
- Che cos'è la 'buona salute mentale'?
- NuovoChe cos'è il bagno nella foresta e può migliorare la tua salute?
- Perché la terapia è così stancante?
- Perché portare a spasso il tuo cane può migliorare la tua salute mentale